Thoughts from the Daf

Shabbat 99b: Three Rabbis, One Opinion

January 22, 2013 By: Rabbi Jay Kelman
James Naismith is credited with inventing basketball, but a primitive version seems to have existed in Talmudic times. “Rav Mordechai asked Rava: [Given] a column in a public area that is ten handbreadths tall and four wide (and thus considered a private domain), and one threw an object, and it landed on top; what is the law?”One may not carry—or throw—an object from a public to a private domain or vice versa on Shabbat. Throwing an object from...
Continue Reading »

Shabbat 96b: Human Revelation

January 18, 2013 By: Rabbi Jay Kelman
Of all the 39 Melachot, it is carrying that, by far, occupies the most pages of Talmudic discussion. In the midst of discussing this prohibition, the Talmud (Shabbat 96b) turns its focus to the Mekoshesh eitzim, gatherer of wood (see Bamidbar 15). Having been stoned for his infraction, the Talmud is interested in knowing what exactly he did wrong, with carrying being one of the possibilities raised. This leads the Gemarah to a fascinating...
Continue Reading »

Shabbat 91b: Talmudic Toys

January 14, 2013 By: Rabbi Jay Kelman
It seems that the toy industry in Talmudic times was quite different than the one we have today. Lacking the technological gizmos so popular today, Talmudic toys were much more attuned to the world of nature. “If one carries a live pure (kosher) grasshopper, it is any size; if it’s dead, the size of a dried fig” (Shabbat 91b). The Talmud meticulously details on an almost item-by-item basis how much one need carry to violate the prohibition of...
Continue Reading »

Shabbat 89b: Yitzchak to the Rescue

January 10, 2013 By: Rabbi Jay Kelman
Abraham is the founding father of Judaism, Yaakov is the founding father of the Jewish people, and Yitzchak is the link between them. His role was that of consolidator, enabling Abraham’s’ revolutionary ideas to survive to the next generation. He is the quiet link, allowing others to shine in the spotlight. Yet, in a fascinating passage, the Talmud (89b) describes how Yitzchak was the one who came to the rescue of the Jewish people.“For You are...
Continue Reading »

Shabbat 89a: Sinai and Sin'ah

January 08, 2013 By: Rabbi Jay Kelman
Years ago, I heard Dennis Prager note that, while the Talmud spends six double-sided folio pages discussing the permissibility of eating an egg laid on Yom Tov, the Talmudic discussion of anti-Semitism consists of about three lines. Our great sages were concerned about how Jews are meant to live their lives, not what our enemies think of us. For the Talmud, the answer to the age-old question of anti-Semitism was as simple as it was profound. “...
Continue Reading »

Pages